Home › Blog › CSR

Is CSR Just Marketing? Five Tests That Separate Real Impact From PR

Is CSR just marketing? Some of it is, and the sceptics have a point: plenty of corporate social responsibility is a photo of staff planting trees placed next to a business model that does far more harm than the trees undo. But "CSR is all PR" is as lazy as "CSR is all good". The useful question is how to tell the difference, and since 2022 UK regulators have been answering it for us, by banning ads and taking undertakings from household names whose claims did not stand up. Here are five tests that work, whether you are judging a supplier, an employer or your own programme.

The short answer: CSR is marketing when it is designed around being seen; it is responsibility when it changes how the core business operates

The quickest test: would the activity still happen if nobody could ever publicise it?

Regulatory stakes: since 6 April 2025 the CMA can fine firms up to 10% of global turnover for misleading consumers, including with green claims

Landmark UK cases: ASA rulings against HSBC (2022) and Shell (2023); CMA undertakings from ASOS, Boohoo and Asda (2024)

Why people think CSR is just marketing

The suspicion comes from a real pattern. CSR grew up inside communications and marketing departments, it is reported in glossy documents rather than audited accounts, and its most visible form, the campaign or the charity partnership, is the part easiest to separate from how the company makes money. When a business spends more advertising its good deeds than doing them, "CSR" becomes a synonym for reputation management.

There is also a gap between what is promised and what is checked. Financial results are audited every year. Until recently, a claim that a product was "eco" or that a bank was "helping the planet" faced little scrutiny unless someone complained.

Where regulators drew the line

Three UK cases show what "just marketing" looks like when it is tested against evidence.

HSBC, 2022

In October 2022 the Advertising Standards Authority ruled that two HSBC posters, run around the COP26 summit and promoting the bank's climate finance and tree-planting, were misleading. The problem was not that the claims were false in themselves but that they left out material information: HSBC was continuing to finance significant greenhouse gas emitting industries. It was a landmark ruling for the financial sector, and the lesson for every CSR programme is that what you leave out can mislead as much as what you say.

Shell, 2023

In June 2023 the ASA banned three Shell ads, a poster, a TV ad and a YouTube video, that showcased its renewable energy products. The ASA found they gave the impression that low-carbon products made up a significant proportion of what Shell invested in and sold in the UK, when the company's business remained overwhelmingly oil and gas. Shell said it disagreed. The principle is the same: spotlighting the small good part of a business as if it represents the whole is marketing, not responsibility.

ASOS, Boohoo and Asda, 2024

After an investigation launched in 2022, the Competition and Markets Authority secured formal commitments in March 2024 from ASOS, Boohoo and Asda's George clothing brand to change how they described their "green" fashion ranges, including being clear about what materials were used and how much recycled content an item contained. Vague labels such as "responsible" or "eco" on clothing had to be backed by specifics.

The stakes have since gone up. Under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, the CMA has been able to fine businesses directly, up to 10% of global turnover, for breaking consumer law since 6 April 2025. Our guide to greenwashing rules in the UK covers the law in full.

The five tests

1. Does it touch the core business?

Real CSR changes how a company makes its money: what it buys, how it pays and treats people, what it sells and what it stops selling. A bakery chain that redesigns its supply contracts so farmers are paid on time is doing CSR. The same chain sponsoring a fun run while paying suppliers at 120 days is doing marketing. If an activity could be deleted without any change to operations, it is peripheral.

2. Is it measured, and would you publish a bad result?

Marketing reports activity ("we planted 10,000 trees"). Responsibility reports outcomes against a baseline, including when the numbers go the wrong way. Look for targets with dates, year-on-year figures and independent assurance. A company that only publishes good news is curating, not reporting.

3. Does it cost something?

Genuine commitments usually involve a trade-off: a margin given up, a profitable product line dropped, a supplier that costs more. When Patagonia's founder Yvon Chouinard transferred ownership of the company in September 2022 to a trust and a non-profit, the Holdfast Collective, so that profits not reinvested go to fighting the environmental crisis, the family gave up the company's value. That is the opposite of a campaign. Most businesses will never do anything that dramatic, but every real commitment should cost something you can name.

4. Would it survive without the publicity?

Ask whether the work would continue if it could never be mentioned in an advert, award entry or recruitment brochure. Volunteering days, matched giving and community programmes can be valuable, but if they are scheduled around photo opportunities and stop when the campaign ends, they were marketing.

5. Is the claim specific enough to be checked?

"Committed to sustainability" cannot be tested. "Recycled polyester makes up 40% of this jacket by weight" can. Regulators now treat vague claims as a risk in themselves, which is why our guide on how to make green claims starts with specificity.

Marketing your CSR is not the problem

None of this means businesses should keep quiet. Telling customers, staff and investors what you are doing is reasonable, and it can encourage competitors to follow. The problems start when the communication outruns the substance, or when the communication is the substance. A simple order of operations avoids most of the trouble:

  1. Decide what matters most in your own operations, using a materiality assessment rather than whatever photographs well.
  2. Set measurable targets and a baseline.
  3. Do the work and measure it, including where it falls short.
  4. Only then communicate, with claims that are specific, evidenced and complete.

Our guides on what CSR is and how to build a CSR strategy go through each step, and CSR examples from companies that got it right and wrong shows what the difference looks like in practice. If you are wondering how CSR relates to ESG reporting, see ESG vs CSR vs sustainability.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is CSR just marketing?

Not necessarily. CSR is marketing when it exists mainly to be seen and does not change how the business operates. It is genuine when it changes core practices, is measured against targets and costs the company something.

What is the difference between CSR and greenwashing?

CSR is what a company does to manage its social and environmental impact. Greenwashing is making environmental claims that are misleading, exaggerated or incomplete. A company can do real CSR and still greenwash if it overstates it.

Can a company be fined for misleading CSR claims in the UK?

Yes. Since 6 April 2025 the CMA can fine businesses up to 10% of global turnover for misleading consumers, including through environmental claims. The ASA can also ban misleading adverts.

How can I tell if a company's CSR is genuine?

Check whether it affects the core business, is measured with dated targets and published even when results are poor, involves a real cost or trade-off, and uses specific claims that can be checked.

Why was HSBC's climate advertising banned?

In 2022 the ASA ruled that HSBC posters promoting its climate finance and tree-planting were misleading because they left out that the bank was continuing to finance significant greenhouse gas emitting industries.

More on building a business that does the right thing is on the E-Business Ethics blog, or start from the homepage.